Finally, Emily West reappears. The torch singer is all confidence and glamour in her evening dress and steady gaze. She eases into the Roberta Flack classic, "The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face." It's a sensual, emotional reading of the song and one she shapes perfectly. As projection effects surround her and even a faux rainstorm streams down, she keeps pushing the song to new places, edging it ever higher to an emotional crescendo. No matter where she ends up in the voting, Emily West has clearly given it all tonight. The judges have nothing but high praise. Howie calls out her risk-taking in her choice and delivery of the song. Howard is equally impressed. "You are the greatest," he tells her. Mel agrees: "If that can't win you a million bucks, I don’t know what can."